The Counter-Drone Ladder: From Shotguns to Lasers
The economics of each counter-drone layer — close-in shotguns, autocannon, interceptor drones and directed energy — and why cost per engagement decides who wins against swarms.
Close-in: shotguns
Ukrainian units have trained soldiers to engage FPV drones with shotguns. Under about 50 m a spread of shot creates a real probability of hit against a fast, small target; beyond that the pellets lose energy and spread too thin. Against swarms it's impractical, but for forward infantry against close-in nuisance drones it's a real tactic that costs almost nothing per shot.
Autocannon short-range air defence
The next tier is rapid-fire autocannon — systems such as the Oerlikon 35 mm or the German Gepard — firing proximity-fused rounds at 600–1,000 rounds per minute. A proximity fuze detonates near the target, so a direct hit isn't needed. Effective against drones out to 3–4 km, at roughly $10–50 per round and a handful of rounds per kill. Economically viable against most threats.
Interceptor drones
Tube-launched, jet-powered interceptors such as the Coyote Block 3 home on a target drone at longer ranges and higher altitudes than guns can reach, at around $30–50k per unit. The limitation: it's still an expensive munition, and against a 300-drone swarm you run out before the swarm does.
Directed energy — the cost curve inverts
This is where the economics finally flip in the defender's favour. Laser weapons like the UK's DragonFire (50 kW) or the US HELIOS (60 kW) can engage a drone for around $10 of electricity per shot, with 3–10 seconds of engagement per target at ranges up to about 5 km.
Part of an ongoing engineering series on drones and counter-drone systems, lightly edited from the original LinkedIn post.